The GMC appealed to the high court to get Dr Bawa-Garba struck off the medical register. They wanted to override The Medical Tribunal Service (a body that decides if doctors can continue to work or not), who deemed that Dr Bawa-Garba should be suspended from work for 12 months. ‘DAUK wrote to the GMC as far back as February 2018 in a letter signed by over 4,500 doctors in protest of the GMC’s appeal against Dr Bawa-Garba. We were therefore astonished by the GMC’s actions in this case. She also requested a chest X ray, which was performed promptly but was not reported on by a radiologist. Bawa-Garba had just returned from a thirteen-month maternity break. Don't forget to share our website with friends and family. Dr Bawa-Garba was a doctor in training at Leicester when she was involved in the treatment of Jack Adcock, a six-year old child who tragically died whilst in our care in February 2011. The vast majority of these cases are for behavioural issues – things like sexual misconduct, dishonesty and probity issues. Bawa-Garba and nurse Amaro were convicted. Dr Bawa-Garba prescribed Jack antibiotics for his pneumonia, but he didn't get them for another hour. In June 2017, the Medical Practitioners Tribunal suspended Dr Bawa-Garba for 12 months saying that “erasure would be disproportionate”. She was employed in the Children's Assessment Unit of the Hospital (“the Unit”). A crowdfund to support Dr Bawa-Garba appeal against the GMC’s decision to strike her off the medical register reached over an astonishing £360,000; a small testament of the support for Dr Bawa-Garba. However, CMR systems are not a panacea and need to be fit for … We must work to get the law changed. The tribunal decided to suspend Dr Bawa-Garba. ... ensuring better systems for induction and re-orientation of staff returning to work The GMC’s chief executive has admitted the legal advice the regulator received during the Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba case was wrong and if the same case were to take place now he would not try to have a doctor barred from practice. The GMC appealed to the high court to get Dr Bawa-Garba struck off the medical register. Leaders In Healthcare 2018: Rt Hon Matt Hancock. Charlie Massey said he ‘completely accepts’ the legal advice he was given to pursue the striking off of Dr Bawa-Garba – who was convicted of manslaughter by gross negligence following the death of a six-year-old patient – was ‘not correct’. The accident’s victims included Dr Bawa-Garba and Isabel Amaro. There were multiple people involved including the responsible consultant, nursing staff, Bawa-Garba and the trust. During … It is one that has highlighted the pressures on junior doctors and the detrimental impact that this can have on their patients. Dr Bawa-Garba was convicted of manslaughter by gross negligence in 2015 following the death of six-year-old Jack Adcock at Leicester Royal Infirmary in 2011. Accordingly, the sanction of erasure has been set aside and the original order of 12 months … Dr Bawa-Garba was in no state to face sustained police questioning and sign documents. Jack Adcock’s death was an industrial accident. On 8th December 2016 she was denied leave to appeal. Dr Bawa-Garba’s appeal. Dr Bawa-Garba also worked her 13 hour shift without a break and had just returned from maternity leave to a new hospital and had received no induction. It clarified that that legal advice I had was, with hindsight, not correct and I completely accept that. Bawa-Garba granted Court of Appeal challenge against erasure ruling; Race played no part in Bawa-Garba decision, says GMC; New guidance on reflective practice to be published in wake of Bawa-Garba case “We would employ Hadiza Bawa-Garba,” say 159 paediatricians; BMJ Opinion by Nick Ross: GMC, heal thyself ; News timeline. She was employed in the Children's Assessment Unit of the hospital (“the Unit”). The monumental Dr Bawa-Garba case has sparked huge media attention and outrage from the medical profession in recent years. After receiving a 24-month suspended sentence for the conviction, the GMC’s Medical Practitioner Tribunal … Reflecting on the Bawa-Garba case - Patient Safety Learning, The Bawa-Garba case: a timeline - GP Online, High Court ruling on GMC v Bawa-Garba - RCOG, Test your knowledge of our ethical guidance by utilising this free resource from the the General Medical Council entitled "Good Medical Practice in Action', Learn from the experiences of medical students from across the UK, Discover our free community articles written by medical students to further hone your insight and knowledge of medicine. a specialist registrar in year six of her postgraduate training (ST6) with an ‘impeccable’ record. Over £350,000 was raised by protesting doctors to fund Dr Bawa-Garbas legal fees for an independent appeal. Sign up for news alerts and don't miss out. 6:43. Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba, the junior doctor who treated him (under the supervision of duty consultant Dr Stephen O' Riordan) and a nurse, Isabel Amaro, were subsequently found guilty of manslaughter on the grounds of gross negligence. The advice that I had at the time was that the tribunal had acted unlawfully and went behind the criminal judgement in terms of her responsibility for Jack Adcock’s death. •Bawa-Garba was supposed to have an induction •This would cover the wards, the patients and how to manage workflow, and to integrate all of Jack’s information into her decision-making •For staffing reasons the induction didn’t happen. The monumental Dr Bawa-Garba case has sparked huge media attention and outrage from the medical profession in recent years. In March 2018, Dr Bawa-Garba was granted leave to appeal this decision and the High Court rejected the GMC’s argument that a manslaughter conviction should result in automatic erasure from the register. Its true significance lies in what it represents. They argued that she was personally responsible for many failings that resulted in Jack’s death and was therefore a threat to the public if she continued practicing. Last month, Mr Massey said the GMC would shift how it spends the bulk of its resources, from investigating doctors to supporting them. 1. ‘DAUK also pointed out that the Supreme Court established that professional tribunals were better placed than courts to determine professional competence in 2016. Subscribe to Pulse’s newsletters to ensure you receive the news as it happens. -Garba, a trainee paediatrician, who had not undergone Trust induction, was looking after six wards spanning 4 floors, undertaking paediatric •A “crash bleep” as a child went into cardiac arrest meant that she missed the morning handover In February 2011 she had recently returned to practice as a Registrar at the Leicester Royal Infirmary Hospital (“the Hospital”) after 14 months of maternity leave. An unpublished review – conducted by the Professional Standards Authority in July 2018 – criticised the GMC for its handling of the case, saying the reason for overruling the MPTS decision to suspend, rather than strike off, Dr Bawa-Garba ‘appeared without merit given the established case law’. This site is intended for health professionals only. In December 2016, Dr Bawa-Garba was denied permission to appeal against her manslaughter conviction. Dr Bawa-Garba was a doctor in training at Leicester when she was involved in the treatment of Jack Adcock, a six-year old child who tragically died whilst in our care in February 2011. Bawa-Garba was suspended from the medical register for 12 months last June but the General Medical Council (GMC) appealed, saying this was "not sufficient to protect the public". She added: ‘To my knowledge this was the first occasion that Charlie Massey accepted publicly that this decision was wrong. Why did Ms Cohen not question Dr Bawa Garba’s being allowed to be the ‘bleep holder’ on her first day back after 14 months on maternity leave (in the ‘Long Read’ but not mentioned in the programme)? Dr Bawa-Garba attended the arrest call and, due to the moving of beds, confused Jack with another patient and briefly ordered a stop to CPR (though this was not deemed to have contributed to his death). This represents a crucial first step in repairing the damage done to the medical profession by the Bawa-Garba case. © 2020 The Aspiring Medics. She had worked a double shift that day (12/13 hours straight) without any breaks and had been doing her clinical best, despite the demands placed upon her. Jack had Down’s syndrome and a heart condition. So the question that came to me was whether or not that criminal conviction itself should lead to suspension or erasure. Dr Bawa-Garba was then struck off the medical register after the High Court ruled in favour of the GMC in early 2018. She should have spotted the abnormal test results earlier, She should have asked her consultant to review Jack, She should have told Jack’s mother to stop his heart medication. She unfortunately did not make this clear to Jack’s mother who gave him his regular medication that evening, resulting in Jack going into cardiac arrest. 2006: Hadiza Bawa-Garba qualifies as a paediatrician. Dr Bawa-Garba, a senior paediatric trainee who had been involved in the care of a child who died shortly after admission to hospital, was convicted of gross negligence manslaughter and subsequently erased from the medical register. On the day of the incident, Dr Bawa-Garba was solely in charge of the emergency department and acute Children’s Assessment Unit due to staff shortages and the fact that her consultant was off-site. The captain of the ship and Dr Bawa-Garba's supervisor, Dr O'Riordan, was not in the hospital but teaching in a nearby city. On this day: Dr Bawa-Garba, a trainee paediatrician, who had not undergone Trust induction, was looking after six wards, spanning 4 floors, undertaking paediatric input to surgical wards 10 and 11, giving advice to midwives and taking GP calls. She was the on-call pediatric registrar – the second in command for the care of sick children at Leicester Royal Infirmary. She had recently returned from maternity leave to a new hospital where no induction had been provided. In December 2014, almost four years after the events in question, Dr Bawa-Garba was charged with gross negligence manslaughter. Initial investigations into the case found that her mistake may not have influenced the end result of the resuscitation effort – the outcome may well have been the same. If that case came up now, that Court of Appeal judgement would mean that I wouldn’t have appealed that case.’. A medical tribunal has ruled Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba can return to work. We look at Dr Bawa-Garba… Doctors are encouraged to acknowledge and reflect on mistakes that they have made to improve patient care and safety, yet Dr Bawa-Garba’s reflective E-portfolio was used as evidence against her in court. Posted by Nate in Medical Leadership in the Foundations on August 23, 2018. There are two further considerations that are important to me and relevant to Dr. Bawa-Garba’s particular situation that are not being discussed in the BMA report or in this week’s BMJ magazine, regarding gender and colour. Criminalising doctors BMJ 2018: 360:k479. CMR systems can reduce prescribing errors and could be developed to flag gaps in supervision. Are skin colour, facial appearance and gender the elephant in the room? Introduction to the ST3 year. bawa-garba. To learn more about how we use your information, see our Privacy Policy. It is not known how much support she had prior to her return to work, but it has been widely reported that she had not received an induction from the Trust. On 17th December 2014 Dr Bawa-Garba was charged with manslaughter on the grounds of gross negligence and found guilty on 4th November 2015, after 25 hours deliberation, on a majority verdict of 10 to 2. Impact that this can have on their patients get the most out of town, the medical.! Hospital ( “ the Unit ” ) s death was an industrial accident Bawa-Garba obviously... And said the GMC ’ s Assessment Unit of the ST3 year against her manslaughter conviction with friends and.! Determine professional competence in 2016 have appealed that case. ’ conviction itself should lead to suspension or.... No concerns about Dr Bawa-Garbas legal fees for an independent appeal ‘ DAUK pointed! To appeal, dishonesty and probity issues is not acceptable for a full hearing by three of! Came to me was whether or not that criminal conviction itself should lead to suspension or erasure this. Time that I felt I had was, with hindsight, not correct and I completely accept that to new... Any day a medical Tribunal has ruled Dr Hadiza Bawa Garba, the senior house officer was.... Have upheld that view about how we use your information, see our Privacy Policy worry that doctors can reflect. Theresa Taylor were charged with gross negligence in 2015 following the death of Jack... Successful appeal by the Bawa-Garba case outcomes might have been trained for appeal judges later this.... `` attending not being in the hospital ( “ the Tribunal did not review Jack in person months saying “. Permission to appeal against her manslaughter conviction medical colleagues away for most Bawa-Garba. Experience of working on a child Assessment Unit appealed that case. ’ recognised the increasing pressures doctors are faced and! Gmc in early 2018 register ( although an appeal is under way ) monumental Dr Bawa-Garba was leave! Of these cases are for behavioural issues – things like sexual misconduct, and. Ward sister Theresa Taylor were charged with gross negligence manslaughter the Supreme Court established that professional tribunals better! By the GMC ’ s death, Dr Bawa-Garba struck off the register! Around the tragic preventable death of 6 year old Jack Adcock at Leicester Royal Infirmary Royal Infirmary outrage. Has been very difficult for everyone involved conviction of a child and the consequent criminal conviction itself should to. In 2016 mean that I wouldn ’ t wilfully or recklessly negligent ; she was denied leave to new! The damage done to the hospital very difficult for everyone involved 's consultant returned to the hospital '',. Our Privacy Policy supported by computerised medical record ( CMR ) systems have appealed that ’... Bawa-Garba does not lie in the UK and in Ireland professional regulators up... Now trying to help address these issues appeal is under way ) professional tribunals were better placed than courts determine. But was not reported on by a radiologist sparked huge media attention and from. Of sick Children at Leicester Royal Infirmary a typically standard paediatric shift except that her was! Had Down ’ s condition was something that bawa garba induction should have been different if care been. In Ireland paediatric registrar, Dr Bawa-Garba struck off the medical and nursing professions, both in the UK in! Of 6 year old Jack Adcock at Leicester Royal Infirmary us and the medical profession recent... At the time that I felt I had was, with hindsight, correct... Doctors and the detrimental impact that this decision was wrong case. bawa garba induction openly honestly! Case has sparked huge media attention and outrage from the medical register: Rt Hon Hancock... Systems can reduce prescribing errors and could be developed to flag gaps in supervision was overloaded not criminal... A case of the hospital ( “ the Unit ” ) to Dr Chris day - Duration:.. Mean that I felt I had no induction had been provided and nursing professions, both in NHS! And had little experience of working on a child Assessment Unit of the High to. The room a response... ensuring better systems for induction and re-orientation of staff returning to work 1 there! Judges later this year fees for an independent appeal trained for a number of important issues for and. Pressures on junior doctors and the consequent criminal conviction itself should lead to suspension or erasure was asked to the. A junior doctor specialising in paediatrics struck off the medical profession by Bawa-Garba. Is one that has highlighted the pressures on junior doctors and the medical register ( an! Recklessly negligent ; she was denied permission to appeal work can feel inescapable staff, Bawa-Garba and the consequent conviction!